Trouble in Toyland: Be Aware When Shopping for Children's Toys

The 25th annual Trouble in Toyland toy safety report.MADISON - The best holiday gift for Bruce Speight would be the end of the U.S. Public Interest Research Group's annual "Trouble in Toyland" survey of toy safety.


But he knows that's a wish that isn't likely to come true.


"That's the goal, to eventually not have to do this report because there's not a hazard on the market," said Speight, in his 13th year as director of the Wisconsin Public Interest Research Group. "Will we ever reach that day? It's the gold standard, but I don't know if it's realistic."


Speight presented the 25th annual "Trouble in Toyland" survey to the media along with Nicole Vesely of Safe Kids Madison and Michelle Reinen, director of the Consumer Protection Division in the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection.


And despite the continuing need for the report, the news isn't all bah hambug.


"The good news is that we are seeing progress," Speight said. "We're seeing fewer choking hazards, we're seeing fewer chemicals in toys, so I think we're making steps in the right direction.


Share This Story

"But we haven't solved the problem yet and there's still work to do."


Improved Regulation of Chemicals, But Not Complete


Speight credits many of the improvements in toy safety to the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008, which revamped the Consumer Product Safety Commission and gave the organization more funding and more regulating power.


The CPSC recalled 500,000 toys and children's products in the past year for violating the lead paint standard, and more than 12 million for violating the levels of cadmium, a carcinogen.


Yet WISPIRG and other public interest research groups across the country would like to see the CPSC's regulating authority further increased.


"For example, the CPSC now has the authority to regulate 14 toxic chemicals in toys and children's products, but there are tens of thousands of chemicals on the market for which there are little to no safety testing," Speight said. "Our children are the most vulnerable to toxic chemicals, so we need to do more."


Speight displayed examples of toys found on store shelves this fall that violate the legal limits of chemical levels or include chemicals not on the banned list.


A set of toy handcuffs and a toy gun showed high levels of antimony. The legal limit for antimony in toys and children's products is 60 parts per million; the handcuffs were found to have 1,200 parts per million of the toxic element, the gun handle had 160 parts per million and the rest of the gun had 94 parts per million.


A children's backpack also was highlighted, because part of it contained phthalates, which are used to soften plastics and have been connected to adverse reproductive and developmental health affects.


The use of six types of phthalates in toys and children's products are regulated thanks to the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, but that means that just "one-tenth of 1 percent of phthalates are banned," according to Speight.


"The backpack contains a phthalate at 15 percent, but that phthalate isn't banned," Speight said. "This is further evidence that we still have work to do in protecting kids from toxic chemicals."


By Any Measure, Choking Hazards Remain


USPIRG's other message this holiday season is a recurring one: Preventing children from choking on small toys.


Over the past three years, 15 children nationwide have died from choking or asphyxiating on a toy or toy part. And it's the leading cause for CPSC recalls, with 5.8 million toys taken off the shelf in the past year for being choking hazards.


However, there isn't a consensus on how to measure such hazards.


The CPSC uses a small, plastic cylinder to test whether a toy is a potential choking hazard. Those that fit in it are banned for ages 3 and under, and a prominent warning label is put on toys for children ages 3 to 6.


"But children have choked on toys that pass the test," Speight said, adding that USPIRG suggests using an empty toilet paper roll as a better test cylinder.


The public interest groups wrote a letter to the CPSC calling for a more scientific review of the small parts standard, and plan to follow up with a formal petition for a review. Consumers can add their names to the petition at


'One Toy-Related Injury is Too Many'


Other tips on toy safety include:

  • Buying age-appropriate toys for children.
  • Making sure safety gear is included when needed, remembering that they are "necessities, not accessories," Vesely said.
  • Double-checking to see if toys not frequently used but brought out for the holidays have not been recalled and are in safe working condition.
  • Creating a safe area for children to play in.
  • Being aware of having older children playing around younger children. Older children can have toys with smaller parts, which can turn into choking hazards in the hands of younger children.

"From our perspective, the health of our kids should be first and foremost - that's why we keep at it," Speight said of the "Trouble in Toyland" report, which has led to more than 150 recalls and other actions during its tenure.


"And I think it's just important that parents and consumers are getting reminded each year of some things to look out for, to make sure we are preventing injuries from happening. Because one toy-related injury is too many."





Date Published: 12/01/2010

News tag(s):  childrenkidssafe kidsouruwhealthparenting

News RSS Feed